Institute for Economic and Social Research – Faculty of Economics and Business – Universitas Indonesia

Indonesia’s Aid Messaging: Recommendations from Discourse Analysis

Mei 28, 2020

Abstract

Development aid always sends a message a development problem(s) that it wishes to  solve. Using discourse analysis and interviews, this paper attempts to clarify which problem(s) Indonesia wants to address with its South-South and triangular cooperation and finds a lack of them. Instead, messages found in the communication of Indonesia’s aid are diplomatic, supported by the principles of demand-driven, solidarity, and ownership. The lack of indication of development objects and expected aid quality combined with an emphasis on these principles may lead policymakers and aid practitioners to prioritize the maintenance of good relationships with recipients and donor partners over actual development impact. This paper illustrates this tendency through the case of Strengthening Gender Mainstreaming JEL Classification: F50; O22; Z13 Keywords (SGM), a triangular program conducted with USAID and Fiji. Despite drastic change in design and a brief tension among the stakeholders, SGM was “successfully” conducted. Vague messaging on program goals contributed to this “success” as preservation of good relationships and attainment of direct diplomatic objectives were more important. Taking the new regulations on business process into account, the paper concludes with policy recommendations.

Download (PDF, 561KB)

Recent Post

The Impact of COVID-19 on Voter Turnout in the 2020 Regional Elections in Indonesia: Do Voters Care About Health Risks?

Maret 21, 2024

Macroeconomic Analysis Series: BI Board of Governor Meeting, March 2024

Maret 20, 2024

Dampak Ekonomi Penyelenggaraan Pertunjukan Musik: Konser Taylor Swift dan Coldplay di Indonesia dan Singapura (Trade and Industry Brief, Special Report, Maret 2024)

Maret 6, 2024

Macroeconomic Analysis Series: Monthly Inflation, March 2024

Maret 4, 2024

Related Post

COVID-19 on Voter

Maret 21, 2024

The Impact of COVID-19 on Voter Turnout in the 2020 Regional Elections in Indonesia: Do Voters Care About Health Risks?

Macroeconomic Analysis Series: BI Board of Governor Meeting, March 2024

Dampak Ekonomi Penyelenggaraan Pertunjukan Musik: Konser Taylor Swift dan Coldplay di Indonesia dan Singapura (Trade and Industry Brief, Special Report, Maret 2024)